BRC urges Government to act without delay on Milburn youth jobs plan
The British Retail Consortium (BRC) has responded to the publication of Alan Milburn’s report, From a Welfare State to a Working State, describing it as a call to action on both a moral and an economic crisis.
Helen Dickinson, chief executive of the BRC, said: “Milburn’s landmark report is a call to action to address a moral as well as an economic crisis. The need for government action could not be clearer. He recognises that preparing young people for work is only half the answer. The other half is making sure there are jobs for them to go to and that requires reducing the cost of employment. Retail is uniquely placed with entry level jobs across the country, but retailers need the confidence and capacity to create those jobs and give young people their first step on the career ladder.”
Subscribe to TRBNICs and youth minimum wage
The BRC backed the report’s call to raise the National Insurance contributions (NICs) threshold for under-25s, starting with retail and hospitality. Dickinson said the recommendation was “not only incredibly welcome, but essential”.
She said 120,000 retail roles had been lost between 2024 and 2026, as the sector’s employment costs rose by £6.5 billion, driven by higher NICs and above-inflation increases to the National Living Wage. “The government must get on and implement this critically important recommendation without delay,” she said.
The BRC also supported retaining the youth minimum wage. Dickinson said: “Maintaining youth minimum wage rates is vital to giving young people a fair chance of getting into work. Retail is a key gateway into the workforce, with one in five people starting their working lives in the industry.”
She added: “Young people with little or no experience already face an uphill battle competing with more experienced candidates, and the last thing they need is anything that makes that first step into employment even harder.”
Employment Rights Act
On the Employment Rights Act, Dickinson said it “must protect workers without damaging job creation”. She said the BRC agreed that the government should adopt a cautionary principle for the new reforms, including guaranteed hours, to avoid making employers more reluctant to hire and shutting young people out of entry-level jobs.
Apprenticeships and the Growth and Skills Levy
The BRC criticised the proposal to cut government funding for apprenticeships for over-25s by 25%. Dickinson said retailers already pay hundreds of millions into the Growth and Skills Levy but use only half of that funding, making it “another tax for too many businesses”.
She said: “It makes little sense to invest in getting a 24-year-old into work, only to make their continued development into better paid, higher-skilled jobs even more expensive the moment they turn 25.”
The BRC welcomed the report’s call for more Levy money to go towards apprenticeships. Dickinson said too much of the money ends up back with the Treasury and that “every pound raised through the Levy should be available to invest in skills and apprenticeships”.
On the proposals to double apprenticeships for under-25s and create a pre-employment apprenticeship, Dickinson called the ambition “laudable”. She said apprenticeships must offer clear progression in retail and the flexibility to respond to emerging skills needs, such as AI and climate resilience, and that the government must enable retailers to use more of their Levy funding.
Work experience, incentives and the Youth Opportunity Test
Dickinson highlighted the importance of work experience, pointing to Opening Shift, through which retailers have joined forces with the government to offer thousands of placements.
She also welcomed employer cash incentives of up to £7,000 for hiring a young person who has been out of work or education for more than six months, and £2,500 for taking on a new apprentice aged 16 to 24. She said support must be simple to access and administer, particularly for employers hiring at scale.
On the proposed Youth Opportunity Test, she said assessing policies against their impact on youth employment “should help ensure we are breaking down barriers to hiring, rather than inadvertently creating new ones.”
There have also been comments on the report from Susannah Schofield, director general of the Direct Selling Association.
Schofield said: “Alan Milburn’s review highlights the urgent need to tackle the crisis of nearly one million young people out of education, employment or training, and makes clear that traditional routes into work are not working for everyone.
“As ministers respond to these findings, one pathway that must not be overlooked is self-employment and entrepreneurship.
“For many young people, particularly those managing health conditions, low confidence or caring responsibilities, a rigid nine-to-five role simply isn’t an accessible first step. Flexible, low-barrier models such as direct selling allow young people to earn on their own terms while building valuable commercial skills and confidence.
“Any overhaul of youth employment support must ensure that entrepreneurship and self-employment sit alongside jobs, apprenticeships and training as recognised pathways into work and economic participation. If we are serious about tackling youth inactivity, entrepreneurship must be part of the solution.”


